AI tools now work a bit like a well-connected friend. Ask them for a good accountant nearby, and they won’t hand you a page of websites. They’ll give you two or three names and a reason to call each one. If your business isn’t one of those names, you’re not in the conversation.
So knowing how to choose an SEO agency now means checking that it can get you into those answers as well as up Google. A good UK SEO agency will explain both in plain English.
If one sells SEO and AI search visibility services but can’t show you where you appear in AI answers, keep looking.
Why Choosing an SEO Agency Looks Different Now
Until fairly recently, hiring an SEO agency was mostly about getting your website higher up Google so more people clicked through. That still matters, but plenty of people now also ask AI tools such as ChatGPT, Gemini or Google’s AI Overviews (the summaries above the normal results).
You can see this in the UK figures. Ofcom’s Online Nation 2025 report found that 82% of UK adults still use Google Search, and around 30% of searches now show an AI Overview. Meanwhile, ChatGPT’s UK visits grew almost fivefold in a year, from 368 million in the first eight months of 2024 to 1.8 billion over the same months of 2025.
People haven’t given up on Google. They’ve added a second place to ask, and if your business isn’t in that answer, a potential customer may never reach your website.
If the acronyms are already making your head spin, you’re in good company. Our own industry still can’t decide what to call this work. Depending on who you ask, it’s AEO, GEO, LLMO or plain “AI SEO”, and there’ll probably be a new one by the time you finish reading. Whatever the label, the foundations are much the same as good SEO, and Google advises anyone hiring an SEO to check that AEO or GEO advice lines up with its guidance on optimising for generative AI.
So you don’t need two agencies. You need one that gets the SEO basics right and can show you how you’re doing in AI answers as well.
How To Choose an SEO Agency
Most proposals look much the same on paper. The differences come out when you dig into the details, so here are the six steps we’d take if we were choosing an SEO agency ourselves.
1. Decide What You Want SEO to Do
Before you speak to anyone, get clear on what success looks like for you. More local enquiries, leads from across the UK, online sales and being recommended in AI answers, each need a different mix of work. Jot down the services that matter most and a rough monthly budget. Enquiries and sales are a better yardstick than traffic, which is lovely to look at but doesn’t pay the bills.
If you run a small or medium-sized business and aren’t sure where to start, the basics usually give the best return: fixing technical problems on your site, clear service pages that answer customers’ questions, a complete Google Business Profile if you serve local areas, and reviews on trusted sites. A good agency will tell you that rather than sell you everything on day one, and a short piece of digital marketing consultancy can help if you’d like a second opinion first.
2. Check What the Work Actually Includes
Most agencies will say they cover SEO and AI search. The difference shows when you ask what that involves.
Look for three things:
- Technical SEO they’ll implement. Technical SEO is the behind-the-scenes work that helps Google and AI tools find, load and understand your pages: indexing, page speed, mobile use, broken links and structured data (code that labels your business details for search engines).
- Content built around real questions. A good agency starts with the questions your customers ask, then makes sure your key pages answer them in the first few lines. An agency offering content marketing services should show how it improves existing pages, not just how many new blog posts it will write.
- Local SEO, if you need it. If you serve customers in specific towns, ask whether your Google Business Profile and location pages are part of the package or priced separately. It’s often an add-on rather than standard, so it’s worth knowing upfront what you’re paying for.
The same things make a website more likely to rank in Google and be mentioned by AI tools: clear answers, a technically sound site, consistent business details across the web and mentions on other credible sites. We cover the practical side in our guide on how to appear in AI search results.
3. Ask How They’ll Track AI Visibility
“We optimise for AI” sounds great in a pitch but means little unless someone measures it. This isn’t only a big-brand concern either. BrightLocal’s Local Consumer Review Survey 2026 of 1,002 US consumers found 45% had used AI tools for local business recommendations in the past year, up from 6% the year before.
Ask which AI tools the agency checks, such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google’s AI Overviews, and ask to see the actual questions (usually called prompts) it tracks for you. They should sound like your customers, so expect a mix of “Which accountant near me would you recommend?” and research questions that start with “How do I…”.
Each month, the agency should tell you whether your business was mentioned, which of your pages were cited as a source and which competitors turned up instead. AI answers vary with wording, location and timing, so judge the trend over a few months rather than one screenshot.
4. Look Closely at Their Reporting
A monthly SEO report should show what changed in Google, what changed in AI answers, and what Ask to see a sample monthly report before you sign.
A useful one usually covers:
- Clicks, impressions (how often you appeared in Google), click-through rate and average position, from Google Search Console
- Rankings for the keywords tied to your services
- Website visits and enquiries from Google Analytics 4
- How often you appear in AI answers, which pages are cited and which competitors show up
- Visits that came from AI tools, where they can be identified
- What was done this month and what’s planned next
The best reports explain the numbers rather than just listing them. If impressions go up while clicks go down, a good agency will tell you why. AI summaries can be part of the story: Pew Research Center found US Google users clicked a traditional result in 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared, compared with 15% when it didn’t. Ranking changes can cause the same pattern, though, so ask how they reached their conclusion.
Reports should also link visits to real enquiries: form fills, calls and emails. If you’re also investing in lead generation services, ask for both in the same report so you’re not piecing it together yourself. It’s worth giving AI traffic its own line too. Semrush’s July 2025 study of digital marketing and SEO topics found the average visitor from AI search was worth 4.4 times a traditional organic visitor, based on conversion rate. It’s only one study, but it’s a good reason to see what AI traffic actually brings in for your business.
5. Ask for Proof You Can Check
Ask for case studies with real numbers, a timeframe and a clear starting point, such as how many enquiries a client had before and after. “We grew traffic” without figures tells you very little. Ask to speak to a current client, too.
It’s also fair to look at how the agency shows up for its own services in Google and in tools like ChatGPT. Nobody is perfect, us included, but a good agency should be able to tell you honestly where it stands and what it’s doing about the gaps.
6. Ask the Right Questions Before You Sign
Before hiring an SEO agency, ask each one the same questions, in the same words, so you’re comparing answers rather than presentations.
Here are the questions to ask an SEO agency before you sign anything:
- Who will work on my account day to day? You want names and roles, not “the team”.
- What will you do in the first three months? Listen for an audit, a priority list, and fixes going live.
- Which AI platforms and prompts will you track? Ask to see the prompt list.
- Who makes the changes on my website? You need a clear split between the agency, your developer, and your team.
- Do you follow Google Search Essentials? Google itself suggests asking this.
- What’s the minimum contract term and notice period? Look for clear terms in writing.
- What do I own if we part ways? The answer should be everything: accounts, content, data, and tracking.
- What exactly is included in the monthly fee, and what costs extra? Ask about content creation, technical fixes, reporting, and any third-party software charges.
Walk away from any agency that guarantees first-place rankings or AI citations. Google states plainly that no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and nobody controls what ChatGPT says either.
Other warning signs include methods the agency won’t explain, link schemes, jargon that never turns into a plain answer, a very low fee with no clear scope, and reports with rankings and nothing else.
Should You Choose a London SEO agency or a UK-wide one?
Choose on fit and evidence first, and postcode second. A London SEO agency makes sense if you’d like to meet face to face or you’re competing for London searches. A UK-wide agency, or a consultant who specialises in AI visibility, can serve you just as well if communication is strong. Either way, the six steps above don’t change.
How WSI Digital Advisors approaches SEO and AI search visibility
We call our approach Search Everywhere Optimisation, powered by WSI AdaptiveSEO®. It brings SEO, authority-building content and AI visibility together in one plan built around your business goals. In practice, that means technical fixes, answer-first content, FAQs, schema markup, AI prompt testing and competitor insight, with a monthly report that connects visibility to enquiries.
One of our case studies is a good example: an interiors construction business wanted its website to start generating leads. The result was a 50x increase in visibility in Google, 13x more visits to the website and 10+ sales contacts a month, from previously zero.
We’re a UK digital marketing agency based in London and part of the global WSI network. When you get in touch, one of our directors will follow up personally to arrange a time to talk. If you’d like to see where your business stands first, find out how our SEO and AI search visibility service works and request a visibility test of your website.
Whoever you speak to, use these six steps as your scorecard. Knowing how to choose an SEO agency now means checking two things: whether it can improve your Google rankings, and whether it can show that your business appears when customers ask AI for an answer.
Frequently Asked Questions About Choosing an SEO Agency
When Is the Best Time to Hire an SEO Agency?
The earlier, the better. Google’s own guidance says a good time to hire is when you’re planning a website redesign or a new site launch, so search is built into the structure from the start. An agency can still improve an existing site, but bringing one in before a rebuild avoids paying to fix problems later.
What Should I Prepare Before Speaking to an SEO Agency?
Have your goals, main services, locations, top competitors, and budget ready, plus access to Google Search Console and Google Analytics 4 if you use them. A good SEO company will ask what makes your business unique, who your competitors are, and how your customers find you, so it helps to have clear answers.
How Long Does It Take to See Results From an SEO Agency?
There is no fixed timeline, because it depends on your site’s starting point, your competition and how quickly changes go live. Ask any agency what results it expects and by when, and get that answer in writing. With AI visibility, look at the trend across several months of tracked prompts, not a single snapshot.
Can I Change SEO Agency Without Losing My Rankings?
Usually, yes, if the handover is planned. Keep ownership of your website, Search Console, Google Analytics, and Google Business Profile accounts; ask for a record of every change made, and make sure no pages are removed or URLs changed without redirects. Rankings belong to your site and its content, not to the agency.
How Much Should I Budget for an SEO Agency?
SEO agency fees depend on your website, competition, business goals, and the work required. Rather than choosing the lowest quote, ask each agency to outline its monthly deliverables, identify any additional costs, and explain what it can realistically achieve within your budget. Compare the scope of work and expected outcomes, not just the price.
What Access Should I Give an SEO Agency?
Knowing how to choose an SEO agency includes checking how it handles access to your website, Google Search Console, and Google Analytics 4. Give the agency appropriate permissions rather than sharing personal passwords, and retain ownership of your accounts. Agree on who can make live website changes and how access will be managed when the contract ends.